Page 1 of 1
belt length dilemma
Posted: Fri May 10, 2024 10:30 pm
by Spike188
I purchase a 446-80 paired with what appears to be a k46 deck. The correct belt for this unit should be a C23359, When installed the belt is out of alignment with the deck drive pulley and will jump off when drive is rotated by hand, plus the idler pulleys are also out of alignment with the clutch pulley.
A74 belts measures 5 inches longer than the EOM C23359 belts but puts all of the pulleys in proper alignment.
I am scratching my head on this one. Is there a difference in the length of the Mule drive for a long and short frame tractor. I have 3 decks and mules but have not found a difference in any of them.
If the weather is nice tomorrow, a deck will be installed and photos taken.

Re: belt length dilemma
Posted: Sat May 11, 2024 10:27 am
by myerslawnandgarden
5" in belt length is a huge difference. A K46 is exactly the right vintage deck for a 1980 tractor and all mule drives are dimensionally the same. There are some differences but nothing to prevent them from interchanging between long and short wheelbase tractors. Hopefully your pictures will help determine the problem.
Bob
Re: belt length dilemma
Posted: Sat May 11, 2024 12:08 pm
by thebuildist
I'm with Bob: this one needs pictures.
Re: belt length dilemma
Posted: Sat May 11, 2024 1:22 pm
by Spike188
This is the deck I have been running with the A74 belt and it should probably be an A73. This picture is with the C23359 belt installed. Notice how it rubs on the mule brace.
This morning I changed the deck but not the mule. This is with the C23359 installed and it is only slightly better.
Here is a shot of the second deck and another mule. This time there is a noticeable change in belt tension.
Both decks have had the mule mounting brackets rewelded and the first mule appears to have a slightly different adjustment arc on the idler mounts. Possibly the previous owner modified all of the wear points and there is a stacked creep on the overall dimensions. I have not been able to find any single dimension that is different by more that a 1/2 inch between the 2 decks. The second deck has aluminium spindles making it a later model deck.
The second deck needs all the spindle bearings replaced. I want this tractor to be the trim mower where there is a chance of hitting a rock. Rocks are just to ruff on the RM60.
Re: belt length dilemma
Posted: Sat May 11, 2024 4:43 pm
by propane1
Only guessing here, but the pulley on the left side, sitting on the seat, in the first two pictures looks smaller than the third picture. And it looks like the arm, third picture, where the pulley is bolted to seems to have a more of a downward slope than the in first two pictures. Some thing is different.
Noel
Re: belt length dilemma
Posted: Sat May 11, 2024 5:25 pm
by Timj
Here's some pics, I had to put a new c23359 on this morning. I had been running the L471 belt that came on the 448 to it's end. This morning it kept turning over so it is done.
Re: belt length dilemma
Posted: Sat May 11, 2024 6:09 pm
by Harry
propane1 wrote: ↑Sat May 11, 2024 4:43 pm
Only guessing here, but the pulley on the left side, sitting on the seat, in the first two pictures looks smaller than the third picture. And it looks like the arm, third picture, where the pulley is bolted to seems to have a more of a downward slope than the in first two pictures. Some thing is different.
Noel
You have a good eye Noel.

I would have never seen that.

Harry
Re: belt length dilemma
Posted: Sat May 11, 2024 8:01 pm
by Spike188
@propane1 Noel, You are correct about the angle of the idler mounts being at a different angle. That is a difference in the 2 mules. The photo that @Timj posted looks like the same version of build that may last 2 pictures show. As Bob said the mules should be interchangeable, but will have a slightly different profile.
The belts used by Case a Colt at between and A and B belt profile. Idlers and pulleys purchased after market are all so A and B profile. If and A profile pulley is used the pulley diameter can be the same as Case but the belt will not nest as deep. If the drive hub and idlers are aftermarket "A" then there could easily be several inches of added travel needed. 1/2" increase on the drive pulley diameter would add approximately 1" and the a 1/2" change on each idler would add about 1".
Since one of my decks had hangers reattached by previous owner, and there is a noticeable belt length change on it, the hangers measure a closer to the front of the deck. What I haven't confirmed is the centerline distance from the drive spindle to the hanger ears centerline.
Bob is sending me an eom drive pulley and it should be delivered Monday.
Stay tuned. In the meantime the when the 446 was purchase it was impossible to start without removing the air cleaner and priming. There is no evidence that it ever had a fuel pump. I plan on putting a 1-2 PSI electric pump on it this week.
Stay tuned.
Re: belt length dilemma
Posted: Sat May 11, 2024 11:14 pm
by myerslawnandgarden
Eugene,
Regarding my comment on the mule drives:
@propane1 Noel, You are correct about the angle of the idler mounts being at a different angle. That is a difference in the 2 mules. The photo that @Timj posted looks like the same version of build that may last 2 pictures show. As Bob said the mules should be interchangeable, but will have a slightly different profile.[/b
The mule drive bracket and pulleys should all be the same, any differences are at the rear of the mounting frame. Sorry for any confusion. I definitely think that there is an issue with the one that came with the 1980 tractor.
Bob]
Re: belt length dilemma
Posted: Sun May 12, 2024 5:51 am
by propane1
Just for fun I’ll get pictures off my 1975 Case 224 today.
Noel
Re: belt length dilemma
Posted: Sun May 12, 2024 6:31 am
by Spike188
Thanks Noeel
Re: belt length dilemma
Posted: Tue May 14, 2024 9:28 am
by propane1
Well after forgetting to get the pictures I said I’d get. Here they are. Hard place to take pictures of. My works well. I don’t if you can see any thing there or not of interest.
Noel
Re: belt length dilemma
Posted: Tue May 14, 2024 8:32 pm
by CaseIngersollNE
Late to the party but the spring looks wrong, looks like the bushings on the mule were messed with or not there as the bolt is not original one one of them. Your pulleys on one of the pics looked smaller too? Think few things were messed with on there.
Re: belt length dilemma
Posted: Wed May 15, 2024 10:46 am
by Spike188
Problem about solved. Previous owner had changed out the deck drive pulley with an "A" instead of an EOM.
Not only was the "A" a tad bigger in diameter
it is not as tall, and an EOM belt rides out of the groove.
here is the EOM belt on the EOM sheave. The next step was leveling the deck and putting the correct spring on the tension idler.
Friends, Thanks for all of the input and advice, now it is time to correct an electrical issue of an intermittent pinched wire somewhere, and then a test mowing.
Re: belt length dilemma
Posted: Wed May 15, 2024 11:53 am
by Spike188
Back to the shop for another week. The grass wouldn't discharge.
well Duh. Who would weld a discharge shut brace in on the vertical? First step us cut it out and make a new one.
Re: belt length dilemma
Posted: Wed May 15, 2024 12:52 pm
by propane1
One in mine.
Noel
Re: belt length dilemma
Posted: Wed May 15, 2024 2:09 pm
by myerslawnandgarden
Spike188 wrote: ↑Wed May 15, 2024 11:53 am
Back to the shop for another week. The grass wouldn't discharge. 20240515_113743.jpg well Duh. Who would weld a discharge shut brace in on the vertical? First step us cut it out and make a new one.
That's how the older decks were designed. The toe brace was removed on the later ones and the deck was reinforced with 1/4 x 1" flat iron welded on edge to the front and top of the deck to stiffen it. if you just cut the brace out the deck will flex and crack at all the welds. At one time you could buy the pieces in a kit along with instructions as the brace needed to come out to use the hydravac if you were putting it on an older deck rather than the "N" series.
Bob
Re: belt length dilemma
Posted: Wed May 15, 2024 7:26 pm
by Spike188
Thanks @myerslawnandgarden Bob, My plans are to add bracing. I will look through manuals to see if the bracing shows up in any of the parts or operators manuals. Hopefully a manual on hydrovacs will show the bracing.
Re: belt length dilemma
Posted: Wed May 15, 2024 10:09 pm
by myerslawnandgarden
Spike188 wrote: ↑Wed May 15, 2024 7:26 pm
Thanks @myerslawnandgarden Bob, My plans are to add bracing. I will look through manuals to see if the bracing shows up in any of the parts or operators manuals. Hopefully a manual on hydrovacs will show the bracing.
i don't think that it is shown in any of the parts diagrams as, I should be able to post a pic and supply dimensions.
Bob
Re: belt length dilemma
Posted: Wed May 15, 2024 10:29 pm
by Spike188
My intent is to use this deck to keep trails and overgrowth mowed. Removing the brace will keep the discharge shut from constantly plugging.
Re: belt length dilemma
Posted: Wed May 22, 2024 11:14 pm
by MattA
Eugene I meant to post my RM48's bracing. If you want basic dimensions let me know.
Re: belt length dilemma
Posted: Thu May 23, 2024 1:59 pm
by Spike188
Thank you @MattA That is what my deck will get. The amount of grass it will discharge now with the brace removed is almost unbelievable. It went from being a lawn mower to a weed whacker.
Re: belt length dilemma
Posted: Sat May 25, 2024 8:16 am
by Spike188
Yesterday was a super productive day. Started breakfast at 6, had our guests out the door by 7:30. Made 3 loaves of bread, and in between changed the muffler on 60" mower tractor.
Had all of the yard and neighbors trails mowed by 3:30. Started baking a roast, and supper at 5:30 when guests returned.
The past 2 weeks spare time went into replacing parts on the 4016 and 446. Starting with the 60" deck receiving a new spindle, new belts, blades, and front gage wheels. And lastly, the muffler, stolen from a parts tractor. New tubes and wheel bearings in stalled on the 4016. The 48" 446 received front wheel bearings, deck drive pulley, new belt, key switch, fuel filter.
Being able to reliably jump between tractors is a joy.
Thanks to Bob his roll in suppling parts.
Re: belt length dilemma
Posted: Sun May 26, 2024 8:09 am
by Harry
Spike you get more done in a day than I can in a week.

Harry
Re: belt length dilemma
Posted: Sun May 26, 2024 8:51 pm
by MattA
Glad you got everything fixed Eugene
